Carbon steel is what professional kitchens use instead of nonstick — lighter than cast iron, responsive to temperature changes, and buildable into a slick cooking surface over time. Made In is the American DTC brand that brought carbon steel to a wider home audience with polished marketing and strong online presence. Matfer Bourgeat is the French commercial manufacturer whose black steel pans have been standard equipment in French brigade kitchens for decades. They approach the same material with different manufacturing philosophies.

Specs Comparison

Material and Construction

Both pans are made from 99% iron and 1% carbon — the same base material. The critical variables are gauge (thickness) and forming method. Matfer Bourgeat's black steel pans are pressed from French mill steel at around 3mm thickness — the same specification used in their commercial cookware. The pan is formed in a single piece including the long handle, which is welded at the joint. The all-metal construction means oven-safe to any temperature.

Made In's carbon steel is approximately 2mm at the cooking surface with an ergonomic handle that's riveted rather than welded. The rivet construction is clean and well-executed, and the handle stays cooler during stovetop use than Matfer's all-metal handle. Made In also adds a small pour spout on each side of the pan, a detail absent from Matfer's purely functional design.

The Matfer's thicker gauge means more thermal mass — it holds heat better when cold proteins are added and is less susceptible to warping on high heat. The Made In is thinner and more responsive, heating and cooling faster. Neither is incorrect — they're different trade-offs between responsiveness and stability.

Seasoning: The Carbon Steel Reality

Carbon steel requires seasoning before first use and accumulates better cooking properties over time through polymerized oil layers. The first seasoning session — stovetop or oven, thin oil coats, multiple cycles — takes 45–90 minutes and produces a bronze-to-black patina. Early cooking sessions may see sticking until the seasoning builds up over 10–20 cooks.

Matfer's black steel surface, because it's formed by pressing rather than machining, retains micro-texture that accepts and holds seasoning effectively. Multiple professional cooks and food writers who've tested both pans report that Matfer seasons more evenly and maintains the seasoning through aggressive use better than Made In's slightly smoother surface.

Carbon steel seasoning is destroyed by extended contact with acidic foods (tomatoes, wine, citrus), by dishwashing, and by soaking. Storage in humid environments causes rust. This is the actual maintenance burden of carbon steel — not dramatic, but real. If you want low-maintenance, stainless is a better choice. If you commit to the care routine, carbon steel rewards you with a cooking surface that gets better for years.

Heat Response and Cooking Performance

Carbon steel's advantage over cast iron is heat responsiveness — you can raise and lower temperature quickly, which matters when finishing fish, searing thin proteins, or cooking vegetables that need a specific texture window. Over cast iron's 5-pound thermal mass, carbon steel's lighter body responds to stovetop adjustments in seconds rather than minutes.

For searing: both pans achieve temperatures that produce excellent Maillard reaction on steak, duck breast, and fish. The Matfer's thicker gauge means a more even heat distribution across the cooking surface, particularly relevant on electric coil burners where hot spots are more pronounced.

For eggs on a well-seasoned carbon steel pan: genuinely impressive. A seasoned carbon steel pan handles eggs comparably to good nonstick, with significantly higher oven temperature capability. This is why professional omelette stations use carbon steel or tinned steel rather than nonstick.

Price and Value

Made In's 10-inch carbon steel skillet runs $99–$109. Matfer Bourgeat's 11.875-inch black steel pan runs $55–$75 depending on retailer — restaurant supply stores like Webstaurant or Amazon's professional kitchen section are usually the best source. Matfer's pricing reflects commercial supply chain economics rather than DTC margins.

For the price difference — $30–$50 — the Matfer is the better value on cooking performance per dollar. The Made In's premium covers brand experience, marketing, better handle ergonomics for home cooks, and US-based customer service. If you strip those away and evaluate only cooking surface, the Matfer wins at a lower price.

One practical note: Matfer pans come coated in beeswax from the factory, which must be burned off before first seasoning. This requires either a propane torch or extended oven time at high heat. Made In ships ready to season without the wax removal step — a minor convenience advantage for first-time carbon steel buyers.

Best For

• Made In 10-inch Carbon Steel First-time carbon steel buyers who want good documentation, ergonomic design, and domestic customer support
• Matfer Bourgeat Black Steel 11.875-inch Experienced cooks who want the best performance at the best price and don't mind the beeswax removal step

FAQ