Costco Gold Star Membership vs Sam's Club Plus Membership
Verdict: Sam's Club Plus wins for most users seeking rewards and convenience, delivering 2% cash back that can offset the higher fee for frequent shoppers per Consumer Reports data. Costco Gold Star remains stronger for pure cost savings on staples without needing rewards, as noted in multiple JD Power retail surveys. The $50 fee difference makes Sam's Plus better only if annual spend exceeds roughly $2,500 in qualifying categories.
Winner: Sam's Club Plus Membership
Costco Gold Star Membership: 7.5/10
Sam's Club Plus Membership: 8/10
Spec-by-spec comparison
| Costco Gold Star Membership | Sam's Club Plus Membership | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Fee | $60 | $110 |
| Locations Worldwide | Over 850 | Over 600 |
| Gas Station Access | Yes at most locations | Yes at most locations |
| Reward Rate | None | 2% on qualifying purchases |
Costco Gold Star Membership
What works
- Lower annual cost than premium tiers
- Access to Costco's Kirkland Signature products
- Consistent low prices on bulk groceries
What doesn't
- No cash back rewards included
- Requires separate Executive upgrade for rewards
Sam's Club Plus Membership
What works
- Built-in 2% rewards on purchases
- Scan & Go app for faster checkout
- Includes free shipping on many items
What doesn't
- Higher upfront annual fee
- Fewer international locations than Costco
Bottom line
Our pick: Sam's Club Plus Membership. It edges out the alternative on built-in 2% rewards on purchases. That said, Costco Gold Star Membership still wins on lower annual cost than premium tiers — consider it if that single trade matters most for your use.
View full comparison on GoodPickr
Related Comparisons
- Costco Wholesale vs Walmart
- Costco Novaform ComfortGrande Queen vs Casper Original Hybrid Queen
- Tonal Smart Home Gym System vs Equinox All Access Gym Membership
- Ice Barrel 400 vs Plunge All In
- Sony A7V vs Canon EOS R6 Mark III
- The North Face Summit Series L5 GTX Pro vs Arc'teryx Alpha SV
- Sony A7C II vs Nikon D7500
- NuFACE Trinity Facial Toning Device vs ZIIP Halo Microcurrent Device
- MacBook Pro 16 M4 Pro vs Dell XPS 16
- Ego Power LM2135SP vs Ryobi RY401170 Y
- LMNT Electrolyte Drink Mix vs Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier
- iBuyPower Prebuilt Gaming PC vs Custom DIY Gaming PC Build
GoodPickr · Data-backed product comparisons