Casper Original Mattress vs Costco Novaform Mattress

Casper Original Mattress wins — Casper Original wins on targeted support and cooling based on RTINGS-style foam tests and Consumer Reports mattress data…

Scores: Casper Original Mattress 8/10 · Costco Novaform Mattress 7/10

Casper Original wins on targeted support and cooling based on RTINGS-style foam tests and Consumer Reports mattress data showing better pressure mapping. Novaform trails in features but leads on warranty length and value per Costco customer feedback. Casper is the stronger pick for most sleepers unless budget or warranty length is the top priority.

Spec-by-spec comparison

Casper Original MattressCostco Novaform Mattress
typeMemory foamMemory foam
thickness10 inches12 inches
firmnessMediumMedium firm
warranty10 years20 years

Casper Original Mattress

What works

  • Zoned support for spine alignment
  • Breathable cover reduces heat buildup
  • Good edge support for sitting

What doesn't

  • May require break-in period of 30 days
  • Higher price than big-box options

Costco Novaform Mattress

What works

  • Thicker profile for deeper sink
  • Longer warranty coverage
  • Often available at lower in-store price

What doesn't

  • Less zoned support than Casper
  • Can retain more heat for hot sleepers

Bottom line

Our pick: Casper Original Mattress.

Browse all comparisons | Trending

Built by Golden Consulting Partners