2012 Ford Escape vs 2010 Ford Mustang

By Billy G. · Founder & Lead EditorVerified May 21 by Billy G.

2012 Ford Escape
2012 Ford Escape
2010 Ford Mustang
Verified Confidence: 85%

Verdict: The 2010 Mustang wins on performance with its 315 hp V8 and quicker acceleration per Car and Driver instrumented tests, while the 2012 Escape leads in practicality with 29.2 cu ft of cargo space and optional AWD. Fuel economy favors the Escape at 23/28 mpg versus the Mustang's 16/24 mpg from EPA ratings. This is a close call only if daily driving needs outweigh weekend fun.

Winner: 2010 Ford Mustang

2012 Ford Escape: 6.5/10

2010 Ford Mustang: 7.5/10

Spec-by-spec comparison

2012 Ford Escape2010 Ford Mustang
Engine2.5L inline-44.6L V8
Horsepower171 hp315 hp
Fuel Economy23 city / 28 hwy mpg16 city / 24 hwy mpg
0-60 mph9.8 seconds5.2 seconds

2012 Ford Escape

What works

  • Spacious interior with 29.2 cu ft cargo behind rear seats
  • Available all-wheel drive for light snow and trails
  • Strong reliability ratings averaging 4.2/5 from owners

What doesn't

  • Dated 4-speed automatic transmission
  • Only 171 hp limits highway merging

2010 Ford Mustang

What works

  • 315 hp V8 delivers strong acceleration
  • Rear-wheel-drive handling praised by Car and Driver
  • Iconic styling with available convertible body style

What doesn't

  • Rear seats are cramped for adults
  • Lower fuel economy than modern crossovers

Bottom line

Our pick: 2010 Ford Mustang. It edges out the alternative on 315 hp v8 delivers strong acceleration. That said, 2012 Ford Escape still wins on spacious interior with 29.2 cu ft cargo behind rear seats — consider it if that single trade matters most for your use.

View full comparison on GoodPickr

Related Comparisons

People also compared

Browse all comparisons

View Interactive Comparison →

GoodPickr · Data-backed product comparisons