1PASSWORD vs LastPass

By Billy G. · Founder & Lead EditorVerified May 18 by Billy G.

1Password
1Password
LastPass
LastPass

Verdict: 1Password wins clearly. LastPass has rebuilt its infrastructure, but its breach history and the ongoing fallout make it hard to recommend when better alternatives exist at comparable prices.

Winner: 1Password

1PASSWORD: 8.3/10

LastPass: 6.8/10

Spec-by-spec comparison

1PASSWORDLastPass
Individual price$2.99/mo (annual)$3/mo (annual)
Breach historyNoneMajor breach in 2022
Security architectureZero-knowledge + Secret KeyZero-knowledge (post-rebuild)
Free tierNoYes (1 device type)
Security community trustHighLow (post-breach)

1PASSWORD

What works

  • No breach history — clean security record
  • Secret Key architecture adds device-level protection
  • Best password manager UX in the industry

What doesn't

  • No free tier for individuals
  • Closed source
  • Secret Key creates recovery complexity

LastPass

What works

  • Rebuilt infrastructure post-breach
  • Familiar interface for existing users
  • Emergency Access feature for beneficiary access

What doesn't

  • 2022 vault breach — encrypted vaults were exfiltrated
  • Trust deficit with the security community
  • Free tier drastically restricted in 2021 (one device type only)

Bottom line

Our pick: 1Password. That said, 1PASSWORD still wins on no breach history — clean security record — consider it if that single trade matters most for your use.

View full comparison on GoodPickr

Related Comparisons

People also compared

Browse all comparisons

View Interactive Comparison →

GoodPickr · Data-backed product comparisons