Tonal vs Hydrow

Tonal wins — Tonal wins for pure strength progression with 200 lb digital resistance and motion tracking per CNET and Wirecutter eval…

Scores: Tonal 8.2/10 · Hydrow 7.8/10

Tonal wins for pure strength progression with 200 lb digital resistance and motion tracking per CNET and Wirecutter evaluations, but trails Hydrow on cardio versatility by lacking rowing capability. Hydrow provides better value at $2695 versus $4249 and supports both modalities in one unit according to Consumer Reports fitness equipment roundups. Choose based on primary goal: isolated lifting v...

Tonal lists at $4,249 while Hydrow lists at $2,695 — Hydrow undercuts Tonal by $1,554 (58%).

Spec-by-spec comparison

	Tonal	Hydrow
weight_range	Up to 200 lbs digital	—
screen_size	24-inch touchscreen	22-inch touchscreen
dimensions	50.9 x 21.5 x 5.3 inches (folded)	86 x 22 x 48 inches
release_date	2018-09	2018-01
resistance_type	—	Electromagnetic with live water feel

Tonal

What works

Digital weights adjust in 1 lb increments for precise progressive overload
Form feedback via 3D motion sensors during lifts
Compact wall-mounted design saves floor space

What doesn't

Limited to strength training only with no cardio integration
Requires professional installation and $49 monthly subscription

Hydrow

What works

Full-body cardio workout with 500+ live and on-demand classes
Integrated strength training via accessory workouts on the same machine
Immersive scenic rowing with real-time leaderboards

What doesn't

Larger footprint than wall-mounted systems
Requires $44 monthly subscription for full class library

Bottom line

Our pick: Tonal.

Browse all comparisons | Trending

Built by Golden Consulting Partners