Southwest Airlines vs Delta Air Lines

Southwest Airlines wins — Southwest wins for domestic leisure travel and families — free bags, no change fees, and competitive fares are the right…

Scores: Southwest Airlines 8/10 · Delta Air Lines 8/10

Southwest wins for domestic leisure travel and families — free bags, no change fees, and competitive fares are the right set of priorities for most US travelers. Delta wins for business travel, premium cabin international flights, and anyone chasing elite status for lounge access and upgrades. The choice is really about whether you're a road warrior or a leisure traveler.

Southwest Airlines lists at $189 while Delta Air Lines lists at $249 — Southwest Airlines undercuts Delta Air Lines by $60 (32%).

Spec-by-spec comparison

	Southwest Airlines	Delta Air Lines
average_domestic_fare	$189 (short-haul average)	$249 (short-haul average)
bags	2 checked bags free, no change fees	$35 first bag, $45 second bag
seating	Open seating (assigned seat transition in progress, 2025)	Assigned seating, Premium Select, Delta One business class
loyalty	Rapid Rewards — points based on dollars spent, no blackout dates	SkyMiles — miles earned on flights, Medallion elite tiers
network	100+ domestic US cities, limited international	300+ destinations, 6 alliances partner (SkyTeam)
on_time	86.1% on-time arrival rate (2024, FAA data)	83.7% on-time arrival rate (2024, FAA data)

Southwest Airlines

What works

Two free checked bags saves $100+ round-trip vs Delta's $35/bag first checked and $45 second — a real family travel advantage
No change fees and no cancellation penalties — any fare class can be changed or cancelled for full travel credit
Rapid Rewards points don't expire and have no blackout dates — value doesn't erode with infrequent travel

What doesn't

Open boarding system (transitioning in 2025) means early check-in overhead or seat selection uncertainty
No international network beyond 10 Caribbean/Mexico destinations — requires a partner for transatlantic or transpacific itineraries
No seat upgrades, no lie-flat business class, no premium cabin — strictly a domestic coach-class airline

Delta Air Lines

What works

Delta One transatlantic business class with lie-flat seats and Michelin-quality catering is a premium product Southwest structurally cannot offer
SkyTeam global alliance enables seamless itineraries to 1000+ international cities with codeshare coordination
Delta's in-flight Wi-Fi (Viasat) is the most consistent and fastest domestic offering — 30-50 Mbps vs industry average 10 Mbps

What doesn't

Checked bag fees add $140+ round-trip for a family of 4 with one bag each vs Southwest's zero
SkyMiles devaluation has been aggressive — redemption rates have declined 35% since 2022 based on TPG valuations
Change fees for basic economy fares remain — flexibility requires purchasing at least Main Cabin fare tier

Bottom line

Our pick: Delta Air Lines. It edges out the alternative on delta one transatlantic business class with lie-flat seats and michelin-quality catering is a premium product southwest structurally cannot offer. That said, Southwest Airlines still wins on two free checked bags saves $100+ round-trip vs delta's $35/bag first checked and $45 second — a real family travel advantage — consider it if that single trade matters most for your use.

Browse all comparisons | Trending