Porsche Macan 2014: 3 of 15 decision facts sourced. Missing: Starting MSRP, Engine, Horsepower, Torque, Drivetrain, Transmission, Combined MPG, Annual fuel cost, and 4 more.
BMW X3 2015: 7 of 15 decision facts sourced. Missing: Starting MSRP, Engine, Horsepower, Torque, Basic warranty, Powertrain warranty, Seating, Cargo volume.
| Porsche Macan 2014 | BMW X3 2015 | |
|---|---|---|
| Drivetrain | Not yet sourced | Rear-Wheel Drive fueleconomy.gov |
| Transmission | Not yet sourced | Automatic (S8) fueleconomy.gov |
| Combined MPG | Not yet sourced | 24 mpg fueleconomy.gov |
| Annual fuel cost | Not yet sourced | $3,300 fueleconomy.gov |
| NHTSA overall | Not rated by NHTSA nhtsa.gov | 5 stars nhtsa.gov |
| Recalls (model year) | 0 nhtsa.gov | 7 nhtsa.gov |
| Owner complaints (NHTSA) | 0 nhtsa.gov | 105 nhtsa.gov |
Recall and complaint counts come from NHTSA — check your VIN at nhtsa.gov.
Not yet sourced — Porsche Macan 2014: Starting MSRP, Engine, Horsepower, Torque, Drivetrain, Transmission, Combined MPG, Annual fuel cost, Basic warranty, Powertrain warranty, Seating, Cargo volume. BMW X3 2015: Starting MSRP, Engine, Horsepower, Torque, Basic warranty, Powertrain warranty, Seating, Cargo volume. No manufacturer, official or retailer source we read publishes these yet; we don't estimate them.
Verdict: On the figures both makers publish, the Macan 2014 leads with fewer recalls (0 vs 7) and fewer owner complaints (0 vs 105). The X3 2015 carries a 5-star NHTSA overall rating; the Macan 2014 is not rated. Only the X3 2015 publishes annual fuel cost ($3,300); the Macan 2014 does not. Neither publishes starting MSRP, engine, horsepower, torque and 4 more decision fields yet.
Provisional pick: Porsche Macan 2014 — not enough sourced decision facts for Porsche Macan 2014 and BMW X3 2015. We don't rank on specs we can't verify.
Porsche Macan 2014: AutoTrader · Cars.com · CarGurus · eBay Motors
BMW X3 2015: AutoTrader · Cars.com · CarGurus · eBay Motors
| Porsche Macan 2014 | BMW X3 2015 | |
|---|---|---|
| NHTSA overall | Not rated by NHTSA | 5 stars |
| Recalls (model year) | 0 | 7 |
| Owner complaints (NHTSA) | 0 | 105 |
| Transmission | — | Automatic (S8) |
| Drivetrain | — | Rear-Wheel Drive |
| Displacement | — | 2.0 L |
Provisional pick: Porsche Macan 2014 — not enough sourced decision facts for Porsche Macan 2014 and BMW X3 2015.
View full comparison on GoodPickr
Buying guides · In-depth comparisons
View Interactive Comparison →Affiliate disclosure: GoodPickr may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through partner links on this page. Verdicts are editorially independent and never influenced by affiliate relationships.
GoodPickr · Data-backed product comparisons · Built by Golden Consulting Partners