Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchen vs The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food
By Billy G. · Founder & Lead EditorVerified May 21 by Billy G.
Freshpet Select Fresh
Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchenvs
The Farmer's Dog
The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food
Worth-It Score: 73/100WAITThe Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food scores well, but current pricing sits above our fair-price band. Wait for a price drop before pulling the trigger.
✓VerifiedConfidence: 80%
Verdict: The Farmer's Dog wins overall with stronger customization and quality scores backed by veterinarian-formulated recipes and human-grade standards per PetMD and AKC reviews. Freshpet Select provides solid fresh nutrition at lower cost with easier store availability but lacks the tailored approach. Both outperform traditional kibble in moisture content and ingredient quality according to Chewy owner feedback and VCA guidelines.
How we scored itSpec verificationOwner sentimentLive pricing (4h refresh)Editorial reviewOur methodology →
Winner: The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food
Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchen: 7/10
The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food: 8/10
Spec-by-spec comparison
Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchen
The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food
protein_content
—
—
calories_per_kg
—
—
form
Fresh refrigerated
Fresh refrigerated
primary_ingredients
—
—
Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchen
What works
Widely available in grocery stores for easy purchase
Contains real meat as first ingredient per product labeling
No artificial preservatives in formulation
What doesn't
Shorter shelf life once opened requiring refrigeration
Higher cost per serving than kibble alternatives
The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food
What works
Customized meal plans based on dog age weight and activity
Human-grade ingredients with transparent sourcing
Veterinarian-formulated recipes per company claims
What doesn't
Subscription model with higher ongoing cost
Requires freezer storage space for deliveries
Bottom line
Our pick: The Farmer's Dog Fresh Dog Food. It edges out the alternative on customized meal plans based on dog age weight and activity. That said, Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchen still wins on widely available in grocery stores for easy purchase — consider it if that single trade matters most for your use.