Verdict: Audible Premium Plus wins for serious audiobook listeners; Spotify's audiobooks are hard to beat for casual listeners already paying for Spotify Premium.
How we scored itSpec verificationOwner sentimentLive pricing (4h refresh)Editorial reviewOur methodology →
Winner: Audible Premium Plus
Audible Premium Plus: 8.8/10
Spotify Premium Audiobooks: 6.5/10
Spec-by-spec comparison
Audible Premium Plus
Spotify Premium Audiobooks
Monthly Price
$14.95
Included in $10.99 Spotify Premium
Catalog Size
750,000+ titles
~300,000 titles
Exclusive Originals
Yes — extensive Audible Originals
No
Monthly Hours
Unlimited (Plus Catalog) + 1 credit
15 hours included
Book Ownership
Yes — credits purchase permanently
Access only while subscribed
Narration Quality
Best-in-class production
Publisher standard
Audible Premium Plus
What works
750,000+ title catalog — largest audiobook library by a significant margin
Audible Originals with exclusive celebrity narrators and multi-cast productions
Monthly credit system — own each book permanently regardless of subscription
What doesn't
$14.95/month adds up — equivalent to $180/year for one credit per month
Credit system is confusing for new subscribers
Whispersync/pause-to-read features require buying the Kindle and Audible versions separately
Spotify Premium Audiobooks
What works
15 hours/month included with Spotify Premium at no extra cost
No separate subscription decision for Spotify Premium subscribers
Catalog adequate for most bestsellers and popular fiction
What doesn't
15 hours is insufficient for listeners who finish more than one book per month