By Billy G. · Founder & Lead EditorVerified May 28 by Billy G.
2014 Porsche Macan
2014 Porsche Macanvs
2015 BMW X3
2015 BMW X3
✓VerifiedConfidence: 85%
Verdict: The 2014 Porsche Macan wins on driving dynamics with quicker steering response and better balance than the 2015 BMW X3 per Car and Driver instrumented tests. The X3 counters with 4 mpg better combined economy and more rear legroom per Edmunds measurements. JD Power data shows the X3 with slightly higher predicted reliability scores for this generation.
How we scored itSpec verificationOwner sentimentLive pricing (4h refresh)Editorial reviewOur methodology →
Winner: 2014 Porsche Macan
2014 Porsche Macan: 7.5/10
2015 BMW X3: 6.8/10
Spec-by-spec comparison
2014 Porsche Macan
2015 BMW X3
Engine Type
2.0L Turbo I4
2.0L Turbo I4
Horsepower
237 hp
240 hp
0-60 mph
6.9 sec
6.5 sec
MPG Combined
20 mpg
24 mpg
2014 Porsche Macan
What works
Superior handling and sporty dynamics (per Car and Driver)
Premium build quality with high-end materials
Standard all-wheel drive with torque vectoring
What doesn't
Higher maintenance costs typical of Porsche
Lower fuel economy than segment average
2015 BMW X3
What works
Better fuel efficiency for daily driving (per Edmunds)
More spacious rear seat and cargo area
Lower ownership costs and widespread service network
What doesn't
Less engaging handling than Porsche rivals
Interior materials feel dated compared to newer competitors