Verdict: The Kamado Joe Classic III offers more included features at the same price. The Big Green Egg wins on brand community and dealer network. For a first kamado buyer, the Classic III is the better value.
How we scored itSpec verificationOwner sentimentLive pricing (4h refresh)Editorial reviewOur methodology →
Winner: Kamado Joe Classic III
Big Green Egg Large: 6.6/10
Kamado Joe Classic III: 8.2/10
Spec-by-spec comparison
Big Green Egg Large
Kamado Joe Classic III
Cooking Surface
18 in / 262 sq in
18 in / 256 sq in
Deflector Included
No — $90 add-on
Yes (SloRoller)
Lid Hinge
Standard
Spring-assisted
Gasket
Felt (replacement needed)
Double fiberglass
Dealer Network
Extensive
Primarily big-box
Price
~$1,049
~$999
Big Green Egg Large
What works
Largest dealer network — local support and parts availability
50+ year brand track record with established user community
Premium resale value — BGEs hold value well on the used market
What doesn't
Felt gasket requires replacement every 1–3 years under heavy use
convEGGtor (deflector plate) sold separately — $90–$100 additional
Lid hinge doesn't hold position without propping
Kamado Joe Classic III
What works
SloRoller hyperbolic insert included — $100–$150 value
Spring-assisted lid stays open at any angle
Double-thick fiberglass gasket more durable than BGE's felt
What doesn't
Fewer independent dealers — less local service infrastructure
Brand community and accumulated knowledge smaller than BGE's
SloRoller requires cleaning — one more component to maintain