2014 Porsche Macan vs 2015 BMW X3

By Billy G. · Founder & Lead EditorVerified May 28 by Billy G.

2014 Porsche Macan
2014 Porsche Macan
2015 BMW X3
2015 BMW X3
Verified Confidence: 85%

Verdict: The 2014 Porsche Macan wins on driving dynamics with quicker steering response and better balance than the 2015 BMW X3 per Car and Driver instrumented tests. The X3 counters with 4 mpg better combined economy and more rear legroom per Edmunds measurements. JD Power data shows the X3 with slightly higher predicted reliability scores for this generation.

Winner: 2014 Porsche Macan

2014 Porsche Macan: 7.5/10

2015 BMW X3: 6.8/10

Spec-by-spec comparison

2014 Porsche Macan2015 BMW X3
Engine Type2.0L Turbo I42.0L Turbo I4
Horsepower237 hp240 hp
0-60 mph6.9 sec6.5 sec
MPG Combined20 mpg24 mpg

2014 Porsche Macan

What works

  • Superior handling and sporty dynamics (per Car and Driver)
  • Premium build quality with high-end materials
  • Standard all-wheel drive with torque vectoring

What doesn't

  • Higher maintenance costs typical of Porsche
  • Lower fuel economy than segment average

2015 BMW X3

What works

  • Better fuel efficiency for daily driving (per Edmunds)
  • More spacious rear seat and cargo area
  • Lower ownership costs and widespread service network

What doesn't

  • Less engaging handling than Porsche rivals
  • Interior materials feel dated compared to newer competitors

Bottom line

Our pick: 2014 Porsche Macan.

View full comparison on GoodPickr

Related Comparisons

Browse all comparisons

View Interactive Comparison →

GoodPickr · Data-backed product comparisons